You can break the shell and still be stuck, poking at a stubborn rubbery skin that won’t tear where you want it to. That’s when things go wrong. You end up pushing shell fragments into whatever you’re cooking, or your thumb punches through and wrecks the yolk.
The scissors sidestep all of it. Because the toothed ring scores through the shell and that leathery membrane at the same time, in one clean circle, the top lifts off intact. The egg pours out whole, yolk unbroken, no crunchy bits swimming in