matters in a well-fitted pan lid: a little extra room prevents strain.
To make it stiffer: Reheat and press two layers of pill bottle plastic together before cutting the strap. That gives you a firmer latch body while still keeping some flexibility.
To make it softer on finishes: Double the rubber band where it touches painted or delicate hardware. This reduces rubbing and helps prevent scuffs over time.
Safety note: Heat plastic only with good ventilation and steady, low, controlled heat, and never use cookware or food-prep surfaces for this