may benefit from your silence, but they know. Giving people a sign-up date does not make you unfriendly. It makes the holiday more sustainable.
Start simple. Pick a date. Offer specific slots. Keep the message kind. If nobody signs up, that tells you something useful early enough to change plans. But in most families, what actually happens is very ordinary. A few people respond right away. A few reply at the last minute. Somebody fusses. Then everyone shows up to a fuller table, the host spends less, and the day